Discussion for William Shakespeare’s Hamlet, Act I
Reading Dates: April 11, 2025 – April 17, 2025
Discussion Questions (Post your thoughts below):
Hamlet encounters the ghost of his father in Act I. How does the presence of the supernatural shape the mood and tension of the play from the outset?
What early signs of Hamlet’s inner conflict do we see in his dialogue with others, particularly in his first soliloquy (“O that this too too solid flesh would melt...”)?
How does Shakespeare use the political backdrop of Denmark’s instability (Old Hamlet’s death, Fortinbras’ threat, Claudius’ rule) to inform the play’s emotional and philosophical themes?
In what ways does Act I set the tone for questions of truth, deception, and appearance versus reality?
Horatio serves as both a friend and a voice of reason. How does his reaction to the ghost help shape our interpretation of the supernatural and the unfolding events?
Additional Thoughts: What stood out to you the most in this opening act?
Themes and Ideas to Explore:
1. Grief and Mourning
Act I opens with Denmark in a state of mourning—and confusion. Hamlet is personally devastated by his father's death and disturbed by his mother Gertrude’s swift remarriage to Claudius. His grief is isolating, and Shakespeare shows how public appearances (court celebration) can clash with private despair. Hamlet’s profound sorrow sets the stage for his later disillusionment and philosophical wrestling with mortality.
2. The Supernatural and the Unseen
The appearance of the ghost immediately introduces themes of mystery, the unknown, and questions about what lies beyond death. Shakespeare deliberately leaves room for doubt—whether the ghost is truly King Hamlet’s spirit or something more sinister. This ambiguity fuels Hamlet’s hesitations and moral uncertainty, and mirrors Renaissance anxieties about the limits of human knowledge and divine justice.
3. Corruption and Legitimacy
Act I hints at moral and political decay in Denmark. The suspicious nature of King Hamlet’s death, Claudius’ hasty ascent to the throne, and the ghost’s demand for revenge all point to a deeper rot within the state. Shakespeare introduces the idea that when the highest seat of power is corrupted, the consequences ripple outward—“Something is rotten in the state of Denmark.”
Background and Context:
The Renaissance and the Reformation: Written around 1600, Hamlet reflects a period of intense philosophical, religious, and scientific questioning. Issues of the afterlife, conscience, fate, and human reason permeate the play and resonate through Hamlet’s internal struggles.
Tragedy and Revenge: Hamlet draws from classical revenge tragedy traditions, particularly those of Seneca, but Shakespeare adds psychological depth and ambiguity. The play is as much about whether to act as it is about how to act.
Shakespeare’s Technique: Notice Shakespeare’s use of soliloquy, which gives the audience intimate access to Hamlet’s thoughts. In contrast to the more public political maneuvering in the court scenes, the soliloquies allow for deep philosophical exploration.
Elisabethan Beliefs about Ghosts: In Shakespeare’s England, ghosts were a common dramatic device but also a source of cultural anxiety. Was a ghost a spirit from purgatory? A demon? Or simply a hallucination? Audiences would have brought these questions to their reading or viewing of the play.
Key Passage for Discussion:
“There are more things in Heaven and Earth, Horatio, than are dreamt of in your philosophy.”
How does this quote reflect one of the core tensions in Hamlet—the struggle between rational thought and the vast, unknowable dimensions of existence?
Teaser for Next Reading:
We will continue with Act II of Hamlet, where Hamlet begins to put on his “antic disposition,” and the themes of madness, surveillance, and appearance versus reality deepen. How do Hamlet’s choices reflect Montaigne’s skepticism and psychological introspection?
Stay Connected!
Join the discussion and stay updated:
Reddit: r/greatbooksclub
Substack: Subscribe for updates and podcast episodes at The Great Books
X (Twitter): Follow and engage at @greatbooksww